Dave,
Java/Struts (arghhhh), has a javascript error helper that generates
Javascript validation, as well as the standard server validation.
It can be nice to have this option to lower the load on the server. But
it
also means that custom validations will have to be translated to
Javascript,
therefore giving double the amount of work (not DRY) for the same
result.
Alessandro
-----Mensagem original-----
De: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] Em nome de Dave S.
Enviada em: sexta-feira, 11 de novembro de 2005 16:38
Para: [email protected]
Assunto: Re: [Rails] javascipt form validation in Rails
On Thursday 10 Nov 2005 05:57, Peter M. wrote:
In PHP I was validating twice: client side and then server side. Certainly
the code was not DRY but it made the user experience quicker and saved
server requests. I thought of the client side validation as optimization
of
the application. In “Agile Web D. with Rails” there is no mention
that I can find of purely client side form validation. Is this just not
the
Rails way?
If people are still doing validation twice like I used to do then I’m
curious how they are handling it. Does it conflict with AJAX in any way?
Hi Peter,
There’s various schools of thought on this, and while I don’t
necessarily
speak for “The Rails Way ™” of doing it, I think a specific
decision
was
made to do it server-side only in Rails.
I think it basically stems from the fact that client-side JavaScript
validation with alert boxes and so on can get rather unwieldy, and since
you
have to do server-side validation anyway, and since rails makes it so
easy
to
do the server side validation, and since validating it in two different
ways
is rather un-DRY, I think that’s essentially the reason Rails uses
server
side validation only.
I may be wrong about this, but I’m pretty sure this was what was said
the
last
time this topic cropped up. Someone else please feel free to correct
me!
Having said that, I wouldn’t be surprised if someone makes a plugin to
do
this
sometime, since it would probably be quite easy to automatically create
the
JavaScript validation code from the model validations themselves.
I’m not certain I’m right about all this - just trying to answer your
email
since nobody else has yet!
Cheers,
~Dave