What's that? You want me to ask more questions? Sure! So I'm writing a pascals triangle program. My goal is to write it in fewer lines than those on the RubyQuiz site. My idea is to use more math, and less programming. So in order for my method to work, I sorta need to recreate nPr and nCr functions. To be official and learn more, I am doing this through a class. However, every time I run it, I get the following errors: pascal.rb:29:in `pascal': undefined method `nCr' for 1:Fixnum (NoMethodError) from pascal.rb:24:in `upto' from pascal.rb:24:in `pascal' from pascal.rb:41 My code: # Pascals triangle class Integer def self.nPr(r) numerator = factorial(self) denominator = factorial(self - r) @permutations = numerator / denominator end def self.nCr(r) numerator = factorial(self) denominator = factorial(r) * factorial(self - r) @combinations = numberator / denominator end end def pascal max_row 0.upto(max_row) {|row_num| holder = [] ticker = 0 while ticker != row_num result = row_num.nCr(ticker) ticker = ticker + 1 holder = result.push end puts holder.join(' ').center(80) } end puts 'How many rows do you want?' max_row = gets.chomp.to_i pascal max_row Any help? Thanks, Ari --------------------------------------------| If you're not living on the edge, then you're just wasting space.

on 2007-05-26 05:58

on 2007-05-26 06:46

Ari B. wrote: > numerator = factorial(self) > denominator = factorial(self - r) > > @permutations = numerator / denominator > end > end Ari, It looks like you are defining--don't remember the ruby term--java calls it a static method. You want an instance method. Just declare it as def self(r) and not def self.nPr(r) because that is called like: Integer.nPr(something) and you want: my_number.nPr(r) Dan

on 2007-05-26 07:58

Dan Z. wrote: > You want an instance method. Just declare it as > def self(r) > and not > def self.nPr(r) Oops. I meant: def nPr(r) Good luck. Dan

on 2007-05-26 12:03

Dan Z. wrote: > It looks like you are defining--don't remember the ruby term--java calls > it a static method. Class methods.

on 2007-05-26 18:11

On Sat, May 26, 2007 at 10:57:16AM +0900, Ari B. wrote: > > def self.nCr(r) > numerator = factorial(self) > denominator = factorial(r) * factorial(self - r) > > @combinations = numberator / denominator > end > > end Of course Ruby has Bignums, but you could make the program more efficient by not calculating such enormous intermediate values and then dividing them. I suggest you cancel out the terms which are common to the numerator and denominator. That is, 9C4 is 9!/5!/!4!, but 9!/5! is 9*8*7*6, so the result is 9*8*7*6/4*3*2*1. Also, you can swap r and n-r to minimise the calculation. Example: def Math.nCr(n,r) a, b = r, n-r a, b = b, a if a < b # a is the larger numer = (a+1..n).inject(1) { |t,v| t*v } # n!/r! denom = (2..b).inject(1) { |t,v| t*v } # (n-r)! numer/denom end (0..9).each { |r| puts Math.nCr(9,r) } As for making these instance variables of Integer (without self.): that's fine, but I'd suggest you make them class methods of Math or of your own module. Whilst Math.nCr(9,4) is a bit more long-winded to type than 9.nCr(4), it avoids cluttering Integer with more methods. Regards, Brian.