Forum: Ruby Ruby bindings

Announcement (2017-05-07): www.ruby-forum.com is now read-only since I unfortunately do not have the time to support and maintain the forum any more. Please see rubyonrails.org/community and ruby-lang.org/en/community for other Rails- und Ruby-related community platforms.
Sam A. (Guest)
on 2007-05-14 04:15
Hi there,

I was wondering whether it would be possible for someone to spend a
moment
of their time to either answer my question, or point me in the right
direction regarding some interesting (to me) Ruby behaviour w.r.t.
Kernel#binding, Kernel#eval and ERB#result.

Here's an example class I knocked up to illustrate my findings:

class Cheese
 def please_dont_burn_me!
   #doesn't work
   eval "stilton = 'tasty'"
   puts "Stilton is " + stilton
 end

 def just_melted_is_best
   #does work
   eval "shropshire_blue = 'very tasty'"
   eval "puts 'Shropshire Blue is ' + shropshire_blue"
 end

 def throw_cubes_in_the_air_and_catch_them_in_your_mouth
   #again, doesn't work
   eval "cheddar = 'the staple cheese'"
   puts ERB.new("Cheddar is <%= cheddar %>").result
 end

 def grated_is_good
   #passing it the current binding allows it to work
   eval "brie = 'best consumed when warm and runny'"
   puts ERB.new("Brie is <%= brie %>").result(binding)
 end
end

I understand why Cheese#please_dont_burn_me! doesn't work; apparently
around Ruby 1.8 any assignments made within an eval aren't available
to the general context (following block-like semantics). However, this
doesn't seem to explain why Cheese#just_melted_is_best works. There is
similar behaviour with ERB#result; by explicitly passing the current
binding, the result method is able to see the variable cheddar.
Interestingly, when these examples are declared outside of an explicit
class declaration, we see slightly different behaviour:

#still doesn't work (as expected)
eval "stilton = 'tasty'"
puts "Stilton is " + stilton

#works
eval "shropshire_blue = 'very tasty'"
eval "puts 'Shropshire Blue is ' + shropshire_blue"

#this time it works...
eval "cheddar = 'the staple cheese'"
puts ERB.new("Cheddar is <%= cheddar %>").result

#works
eval "brie = 'best consumed when warm and runny'"
puts ERB.new("Brie is <%= brie %>").result(binding)

I guess my question is: is there an easy way of explaining and
understanding how bindings operate in    these situations, or is the
answer just due to the quirks of the c implementation?

Yours,

Sam A.

---
http://sam.aaron.name
This topic is locked and can not be replied to.